顯示廣告
隱藏 ✕
※ 本文為 MindOcean 轉寄自 ptt.cc 更新時間: 2019-03-18 14:25:23
看板 HatePolitics
作者 wishcrystal ()
標題 [轉錄] 陳冠廷臉書
時間 Mon Mar 18 08:35:12 2019



1.轉錄網址︰http://tinyurl.com/y2xemb7p
 
https://imgur.com/USsj1tX
[圖]
 
黎安友教授與市長早餐會,談兩岸、台美關係。

市長的政策,一直以來因為跟台灣主要政黨不同,也因為加上一些「科學」色彩,所以常
常會被評為有趣,或者是有想法。

至於黎安友教授說了什麼,以下是他接受採訪的回答。

Q: What did you think of your meeting with the mayor?
A: I enjoyed meeting him. He is very straightforward and uses a lot of
interesting quotations.

問:您與市長會面的如何?
答:我很高興見到他。他非常直率而且使用了很多有趣的引言。

Q: We know that the mayor has used “bank robbery” as a comparison to
describe US-China-Taiwan relations. It’s a bit controversial in Taiwan. Did
he reiterate this analogy during your meeting?
A: No, he did not.
Q: Do you agree with that analogy?
A: I don’t want to speak for the mayor and say what is policy is because
this is the first time I’ve met him, so I don’t believe I fully understand
his position.

問:我們知道市長曾經用“銀行搶劫”作為比較來描述美中台關係。這個比較在台灣其實
具有爭議性。他在會議期間是否重申了這個比喻?
答:沒有。
問:你同意這個比喻嗎?
答:我不想代表市長說他的政策是什麼,因為這是我第一次和他見面,所以我不相信我完
全理解他的立場。

Q: What was your impression about his stance on cross strait relations? What’
s your reaction to his stance?
A: I think he’s very thoughtful on this question, and I’m interested to
better understand in the future how his strategy would differ from the
strategies of Ma Ying-jeou and Tsai Ing-wen. That’s a very subtle question.
So we only had a preliminary understanding of what his thinking is. I don’t
have a deep understanding.

問:他對兩岸關係的立場讓你有什麼印象?你對他的立場有什麼反應?
答:我認為他對這個問題非常深思熟慮,我有興趣更加理解他的策略與馬英九和蔡英文的
策略有何不同。這是一個非常微妙的問題。所以我們只對他的想法有了初步的了解,我沒
有深刻的理解。


Q: Andrew, you mentioned before that Washington is satisfied with Tsai and Ma
because of their background as lawyers and they are very clear careful with
their use of words. The mayor is different, he is very unique. He speaks his
mind. Do you think that if he ran for president, would that be a concern for
Washington?
A: This is my own opinion. I think Washington will be very curious to deeply
understand his positions and to understand what he’s going to do in the
future. I think he will be very interested in understanding the point of view
of Washington. And I suppose that he and Washington will come to an
understanding, and Washington will probably be ok with him as a candidate for
the presidency.

問:Andrew,你之前提到華府對蔡總統和馬總統很滿意,因為他們有律師的背景,而且他
們對言語的使用非常謹慎。市長不同,他很獨特。他說出自己的想法。你認為如果他競選
總統,這對華府來說會是一個問題嗎?

答:我認為華盛頓會非常好奇地去深入理解他的立場,並了解他未來有什麼打算。我認為
他也對了解華府的觀點非常感興趣。我假設他和華府能相互了解,而華府也可能會對於他
擔任總統候選人沒有太多意見。


Q: Mayor Ko believe China and Taiwan are one family. What do you think about
that?
A: My own view is that Taiwan people are more and more forming an identity
that is separate from mainland people’s identities. If in the future, China
changes a lot and becomes much more democratic, that identity question would
change again. And Taiwan people might at that time feel closer to the
mainland in terms of identify. But for now, I don’t see the trend as one
family.

問:柯市長認為中國和台灣是兩岸一家親。你覺得如何?
答:我個人認為台灣人越來越形成一種與大陸人不同的身分認同。如果將來,中國發生了
很大變化,變得更加民主,那麼身分認同的問題就會再次發生變化,而那時台灣人民在認
同方面便可能更接近大陸。但就目前而言,我並不認為這個趨勢是兩岸一家親。


Q: Andrew, you talk about US-China relations as maybe there’s a new cold
war. I wonder if you mentioned that to the mayor. And Taiwan is in a very
delicate situation to be caught in between. Did you give him any advice on
how to handle this situation better?
A: I didn’t talk to him about this idea of a new cold war, which is not my
idea, I think many people see this problem happening. I didn’t give him any
suggestions either because that’s not my place. I asked a lot of questions
because I’m trying to understand how view and the view of other people saw
as well about how Taiwan should… as you said, Taiwan is in a different
situation, so I’d like to understand how different people in Taiwan should
think Taiwan should handle this situation.

問:Andrew,你談到美中關係可能是一場新的冷戰。我想知道你是否向市長提到了這一點
。台灣陷入非常微妙的境地。你有沒有給他任何關於如何更好地處理這種情況的建議?
答:關於新冷戰的這個想法,我沒有和他談過,這不是我的想法,我想很多人都看到這個
問題正在發生。我沒有給他任何建議,因為那不是我的領域。我問了很多問題,因為我試
圖理解其他人的觀點和看法,以及台灣應該如何......正如你所說,台灣處於不同的情況
,所以我想了解不同的台灣人認為台灣應該如何處理這種情況。


Q: Do you think he would be good president?
A: I don’t think it’s appropriate for me to take a position on that. I
think if he Taiwan people elect him, then he will be a good president. But I’
m not a voter.

問:你認為他會成為好總統嗎?
答:我不認為我對此表達立場是合適的。我想如果台灣人民選他,他就會成為一個好總統
,但我不是選民。



陳副發言人真的很專心在幫阿北陳述事實
阿北身邊有這樣的幕僚真的很好
改變成真~持續發生

--




     0』︵_______________________________
     /﹃

--
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 60.245.35.108
※ 文章代碼(AID): #1SZkV4hi (HatePolitics)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/HatePolitics/M.1552869316.A.AEC.html
yuxds: 推1F 03/18 08:37
paul31788: 推!2F 03/18 08:38
rexyeah: 柯黑還在想要怎麼噓3F 03/18 08:38
gibbs1286: 感覺滴水不漏欸,所以訪問結合起來,還是不知道他們聊4F 03/18 08:38
gibbs1286: 了什麼
ya870801: 推6F 03/18 08:38
Lekas: 看他們的問答對談 都很謹守自己的專業領域7F 03/18 08:39
johnhahaha: 推8F 03/18 08:39
sharkimage: 推9F 03/18 08:40
Lekas: 而且會檢視自己瞭解到甚麼程度10F 03/18 08:40
gibbs1286: 所以我很好奇他們兩個真正對談的內容是什麼11F 03/18 08:41
qoomai: 推冠廷12F 03/18 08:41
Marchosias: 這個人才13F 03/18 08:41
LoveIvy: 不錯 阿童有路到一點點 但是只是轉述14F 03/18 08:42
omage: 這問問題的根本就是要釣魚吧?15F 03/18 08:43
sbw0115: 推16F 03/18 08:44
gibbs1286: 我覺得不是釣魚,而是一般人都以為他們會談到這些,結17F 03/18 08:45
gibbs1286: 果似乎根本都沒聊到
qoomai: 這是黎安友被聯訪的問答,冠廷算是做了逐字稿,因為感覺新19F 03/18 08:46
qoomai: 文標題有點誤導吧
devidevi: 冠廷能補幕僚不足真好21F 03/18 08:47
geordie: 真正的考卷在傳統基金會的那場啦22F 03/18 08:47
seventhmoon: 推一下23F 03/18 08:47
jonathan8032: 推逐字稿24F 03/18 08:49
yuxds: 考啥有差嗎 就算美國支持柯文哲選總統 綠粉也是會反對25F 03/18 08:50
f016tw: 他有去喔?這次是不是四大幕僚都去啦?26F 03/18 08:53
qoomai: 小牛沒去喔,而且小牛有說阿北去美國,市府一樣7.30開會27F 03/18 08:55
Chuckj: 推28F 03/18 08:57
birderent: 推29F 03/18 09:05
c1951: 推一個30F 03/18 09:06
Tiphareth: 這次是換學姐去31F 03/18 09:07
outlookterry: 推完整逐字稿32F 03/18 09:13
kk8921647: 推33F 03/18 09:14
gm3252: 推34F 03/18 09:14
kuloda: 超優的陳冠廷,柯P第二任找他真的找對了35F 03/18 09:32
Hayleybear: 推36F 03/18 09:32
burgers: 心存善念盡力而為37F 03/18 09:44
cccon1ine: 喔喔喔 對陳冠廷的看法越來越正面了!38F 03/18 10:06
wistonlin: 推39F 03/18 11:14
ainokodoba: 推40F 03/18 11:14
jay70134: 推41F 03/18 12:29

--
※ 看板: HatePolitics 文章推薦值: 0 目前人氣: 0 累積人氣: 41 
分享網址: 複製 已複製
r)回覆 e)編輯 d)刪除 M)收藏 ^x)轉錄 同主題: =)首篇 [)上篇 ])下篇